GEICO total-loss settlements
What GEICO publishes about valuing a totaled car, quoted from its own claims pages — and the rules your state applies to any insurer, whichever one you are with.
What GEICO says
“These factors determine your vehicle's actual cash value: Your vehicle's mileage, Features, add-ons, and modifications, Any damage before the claim incident, Recent sales prices of similar vehicles in your area”
https://www.geico.com/claims/claimsprocess/total-loss-process/ · read Sep 4, 2026
“Can you choose to keep your totaled car? That depends on the state where you live. Ask your assigned adjuster about your state's rules for total loss vehicles. We'll adjust your settlement amount if you decide to keep your totaled car.”
https://www.geico.com/claims/claimsprocess/total-loss-process/ · read Sep 4, 2026
What else GEICO publishes
Quoted from its own claims pages, with the day each was read. These are the points where carriers differ from one another in writing — how long a rental lasts, what happens if you keep the car, who the check is made out to.
“GEICO will pay for a rental if you have rental reimbursement coverage or other applicable coverage. The total number of rental days is based on the circumstances of your claim.”
https://www.geico.com/claims/claimsprocess/total-loss-process/ · read Sep 6, 2026
“If the settlement amount is less than what you owe, you'll be responsible for paying the balance of your loan”
https://www.geico.com/claims/claimsprocess/total-loss-process/ · read Sep 6, 2026
What that page doesn’t cover
As of Sep 6, 2026, GEICO’s published total-loss page does not address sales tax and fees, how to dispute the valuation or the valuation vendor.
That is not a criticism, and it is not unusual — every carrier we looked at is silent on most of the same points, and a claims page is not a policy document or a summary of state law. It matters only because those are three of the things most likely to be worth money on your settlement, and you will not find them there. You will find them below.
What your state requires, of any insurer
These rules bind GEICO the same as everyone else. They are the part of the settlement that does not depend on which company you are with, and they are where a low offer is most often arguable.
- Sales tax, title and fees, state by state
Whether tax is owed at all, and whether it waits until you replace the car. The most commonly missing line on a settlement.
- How long GEICO has to respond, in your state
Acknowledge, decide and pay, with the day type each period is counted in.
- Your state’s full rule row
All twelve fields, each quoted from the regulation it cites.
If the offer looks low
Ask for the valuation report itself rather than the offer letter, then check three things: where the comparable vehicles came from, whether every deduction has something behind it, and whether there is a sales tax line at all. Those are the same three checks regardless of carrier.
The guides on comparable vehicles, condition adjustments and writing a counteroffer go through each in turn.
Sources and last checked
Every quotation above is verbatim from GEICO’s own pages, linked at the point it appears and dated when we read it. We have no relationship with GEICO and are not paid by any insurer. State rules are rendered from ClaimMath’s ledger and carry their own citations — see how we verify.
Check your GEICO valuation report
Free, no account, and the file isn’t stored.
Start the free audit